We use cookies and other similar technologies (Cookies) to enhance your experience and to provide you with relevant content and ads. By using our website, you are agreeing to the use of Cookies. You can change your settings at any time. Cookie Policy.

Column 2

Sandy Kemsley

Mashup goes un-Camp

Vote 0 Votes

This entry cross-posted to my new blog location.

Slightly against the spirit of a true unconference, the Mashup Camp scheduled for next month in Mountain View has gone commercial. From an email that I received late last week from David Berlind, one of the organizers:

If you're a Mashup Camp veteran, the you know that Mashup Camp and Mashup University have traditionally been free events to attend and Doug and I have worked hard to keep them that way. However, given the number of no-shows as well as the number of non-sponsoring solution providers that come to Camp to commercially engage the mashup community, Doug and I are instituting a tiered fee structure that our research with you indicates is very fair.

Although the fee is nominal ($35) for developers, I don't actually develop much code so have listed myself as an "observer" at past events: I attend primarily to learn and contribute ideas, and to blog about the experience. David and I exchanged some email, and he said that it was cool for me to attend at the developer price as long as I wasn't there representing a corporate entity trying to sell something to the developers (as if I'd pick people with no money as a target market :) ). Non-sponsoring private companies pay $495, and $995 for VCs and public companies.

Something doesn't quite jive with the literal content of his letter, however: the two Mashup Camps that I attended last year were sponsored by deep-pocketed companies like Google and Yahoo, and I'm unaware of any great financial shortfall in running the unconferences (unless David and Doug want to start taking all-expense-paid trips to Tahiti). Furthermore, the no-show rate seemed to be well within expected parameters: keep in mind that there's no-shows at paid conferences, too, and the loss of $35 isn't exactly going to incent a developer to travel across the country if something better comes up. I've been involved in a number of Camp events here in Toronto, and yes, there are no-shows, which means that there's some extra food at the end of the day; deal with it, or maybe stop pretending that there's not tons of food thrown away at corporate facilities in Silicon Valley every day. I've also found the ratios of developers:non-developers pretty good at Mashup Camp in the past, so I don't think that this is strictly to discourage non-developers.

It appears that they're really doing this to encourage sponsorship of the event: I'm sure that the companies that do kick in some money might be a bit peeved that other companies could just show up for free and schmooze around with the developers, dangling job offers. Basically, the $495/995 amounts to an entrance fee to a talent fair, since many of the developers are attending Mashup Camp -- at least in part -- to showcase their talents in front of exactly those people from commercial organizations who might want to hire them.

Personally, I don't think that this is the right way to go about it: I'd prefer to see a consistently low pricing structure (or free) but restrictions on the number of non-developers allowed. Sure, someone could lie and say they were a developer when they're really a recruiter for Google, but it's just as easy for someone to do that now, and just sign up for the $35 package. If you're going to call something a Camp, it really should follow unconference guidelines to some degree, which traditionally includes free (or nearly so) admission, and completely participant-driven content that's not determined in advance. If you're going to run a commercial conference, then it's unreasonable to expect people to pay $500 or $1000 for an event that doesn't even have an agenda published: in other words, you can't really do a commercial unconference event since many companies could find it difficult to justify the cost based on a complete lack of information about content in advance.

That being said, I found the two Mashup Camps that I attended last year were great, and I've already signed up for the one in July. And I'm not just saying that because I ran into David today at Enterprise 2.0

Our Popular BPM Bloggers