August 29, 2008   Sign In |  About ebizQ |  Contact Us |  Join ebizQ Gold Club
Brenda Michelson
Business-Driven Architect
Brenda Michelson, Principal of Elemental Links, shares her view on architectural strategies, technology trends, business, and relevance.

« Quick Poll: What does your enterprise architecture group deliver? | Main | New SOA Consortium Podcast: David Butler on SOA Transformation »

July 24, 2008
The Question is Not "to ESB or Not to ESB," But How to Adapt

When a friend forwarded me Joe's excellent ESB vitriol post analyzing the current round of "ESB-hate" -- sparked by a Dave Linthicum post -- my first thought was to respond on Dave's ESB technology point.  Not from a product point-of-view.  Rather, a technology architecture point-of-view.  Then, the question is not "to ESB, or not to ESB", but what infrastructure services does your organization require to be successful with SOA. Then, and only then, determine the most appropriate products to provide those services.  And don’t forget to look at what you already have in-house.   Boringly, I've been singing this tune since I wrote my "Networked Integration Environment" and related SOA and ESB series for PSG in 2005.

But then, I saw a link for Neil Ward-Dutton's post flow by on Twitter (yes, I tweet), and knew what I should really do was amplify Neil's words on the architectural purity aspect:

"As any experienced IT staffer who's been on the sharp end of a big business merger or acquisition, or even a radical change of leadership, will tell you, businesses don't act like machines that EAs can simply steer so that they tend towards technology optimisation. In fact, it's the opposite: business change forces (new competitors, new product launches, new market launches, new regulations, mergers and acquisitions, and so on) will always drive entropy, tending to push IT estates towards chaos. The best value an EA team can really provide in this environment is to help the IT organisation to absorb these changes with as little stress as possible, and drive consistent, planned responses."

In the words of American poet Charles Olson, "What does not change is the will to change". So, what are doing to inject adaptation into your architecture?

Posted by brendamichelson in SOA |Digg This|Add to del.icio.us

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.ebizq.net/mt/mt-tb.cgi/3596

Comments Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

We ask that you type your code (displayed below) in the text box.This code is an image that cannot be read by a machine. It prevents automated programs from submitting comments.


Code:



Most Recent ebizQ Blog Entries
ADVERTISEMENT
Subscribe
BDA Feed
BDA Comments Feed

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

My Work
Search Brenda's Blogs

Powered by Rollyo
This Work
Accountability:The opinions expressed in this blog are solely representative of the blog's author, and not of ebizQ

Creative Commons License
Blogosphere

Subscribe to our Newsletters
ebizQ Weekly Gold Club Update
Live Webinar Updates
Updates from ebizQ Partners
ebizQ SOA Update
ebizQ BPM Update
ebizQ Security Update
ebizQ BI Update
ebizQ Open Source Software Update
Virtual Show Newsletter
ebizQ Web 2.0 and the Enterprise
Your E-mail Address:
The Future of Application Servers in the Enterprise & IBM WebSphere Application Server V7
Date: Sep 10, 2008
Time: 12:00 PM ET
(16:00 GMT)

REGISTER TODAY!
How to Get a BPM Initiative off the Ground
Date: Sep 16, 2008
Time: 12:00 PM ET
(16:00 GMT)

REGISTER TODAY!
Archived Webinars | Upcoming Webinars

Marketing Solutions | Feedback | About ebizQ | Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Site Map

Live Chat